Welcome to Donatello's
Donatello's offers a cozy and casual dining experience right in the heart of Niagara Falls. This counter-serve gem specializes in pizza, chicken, and sandwiches, making it a convenient stop for quick bites, family dinners, or a comforting meal after exploring the nearby attractions. With a notably local twist, Donatello's weekly fish fry showcases their commitment to community and fresh ingredients. The atmosphere feels welcoming, and the staff prides themselves on providing a genuinely friendly service. Expect a delightful mix of flavors within a price range that makes it accessible for everyone—easily falling between $10 and $20. Whether visiting for lunch or dinner, Donatello’s ensures that every meal is packed with flavor and warmth.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
Donatello's sits at 466 3rd St, a mere stone's throw from the iconic Niagara Falls, which makes it an ideal stop for both tourists and locals alike. The restaurant fits right into the casual dining scene, offering a relaxed, no-frills atmosphere perfect for unwinding after a day of sightseeing. Its strategically convenient location makes it a favorite among visitors, especially those staying in nearby hotels, like the Seneca Hotel.
Accessibility is a key feature here, with a wheelchair-friendly entrance and seating options. The layout fosters a community vibe, often bustling with groups, families, and university students enjoying their favorite comfort foods. Donatello's honors classic dining traditions with a little extra charm. Frequent patrons often rave about their experiences, forming a vibrant local hub as they enjoy hearty meals together.
Open every day of the week, you won't have to worry about missing out on the delicious offerings. Peak times usually align with typical meal hours, especially Fridays when the restaurant is packed. The homey vibe and the promise of delightful meals create reliable repeat visitors, making it a staple in the Niagara Falls culinary scene.
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
One of the standout features of Donatello's is their fresh ingredients; reviews consistently highlight the quality of their pizza, which boasts a lovely balance of crispy yet thick crusts. Flavors burst with each bite, leaving patrons eager to return for more. The wings are a specific favorite, often described as large, crispy, and generously sauced, which complements their pizza offerings perfectly.
The weekly fish fry draws a crowd for its freshness and delicious coatings, attracting seafood enthusiasts. Fast service also earns rave reviews, ensuring patrons enjoy meals quickly, whether dining in or taking out. Customers also appreciate the warm atmosphere, where a sense of community shines through, making each visit feel special.
Most Disliked
While the experience at Donatello's is mostly positive, some patrons noted occasional waits during peak times, especially on Fridays. The hustle and bustle can sometimes lead to minor service delays, though most agree that the food quality makes it worth the wait. Additionally, a couple of diners mentioned that on busy nights, the noise level can rise, creating a boisterous environment that may not suit everyone.
A few visitors also expressed a desire for more diverse vegetarian options. Even though Donatello’s does offer vegetarian dishes, some diners felt that more choices could enhance the experience for non-meat eaters. Nevertheless, most feedback reflects satisfaction, often overshadowing these minor drawbacks.
Reviews
Stefanie J.
We wanted pizza on our last night and found this local spot. Waiting for our food we could tell it has a lot of regulars. We live in Florida where pizza sucks, and we are from IL so we love our Chicago pizza, but THIS pizza was AMAZING! You can tell that the ingredients are fresh. The crust is light and crispy even though it’s thicker. I’m kind of bummed we waited to try it on our last night, I would have gone again! We also got wings which were fresh and huge! They had a good crisp on them and the sauce was great!
Bryan S.
The best pizza place in Niagara Falls. If you want something real and authentic go here. They made us feel at home. This place isn't just open during the tourist busy season. It is a family owned place that will take care of you with great service and amazing food!
Jane D.
We're glad we decided to check this place out. It's a nice mom and pop restaurant that was close to where we were and saw the good ratings. Well, we have to say this place did not disappoint! Their dough and ingredients are made fresh and you can definitely taste it. Some pizza doughs in other places are inconsistent with their texture, but when we cut into their pizza, it seeme like a good texture-- consistent all around. Unsure if they serve the thin crust as an option, but I like how their dough wasn't "doughy" or too thin. Their customer service was great also! They have that "back in the day" old school treatment where you can sit down, eat, and pay when you're done. Their cookies were delicious too! They are very close to a few of the hotels (like the Seneca Hotel) and very close to the Niagra Falls.
Emily K.
Went in last night for pizza and it was amazing. Service was wonderful. This was our first time we live about 3 hours away and will definitely come back next time we visit the area.
Laura
I ordered the buffalo chicken finger salad as carryout and it was delicious! Everything in the salad was very fresh and it was fully loaded with buffalo chicken and vegetables. Staff was friendly and service was fast.
Tess S.
Very friendly atmosphere.(with Ninja turtle decor) You could tell it's a well known spot for locals. The counter guy knew a few people by name when they walked in and the phone orders were consistently coming in. It's not anything fancy, order at the counter(grab a menu and sit while you figure out what you want, then go back up to order), grab your own drinks from the cooler. They will bring your food to you when its ready and pay before you leave. Gentleman at the counter just made the experience better leaving me smile more than once. It's an old school New York style place. Glad I stumbled upon it and decided to stop before heading out of town after a weekend at the falls. The food was delicious. Wish I lived closer because I wanted to try more of the menu. It was a hard choice because it all sounded so good. Then after eating there, there so much more I want to try! I had the Greek wrap and my boyfriend had the Royal Hoagie. The only thing he regrets is not ordering the large because it was so good! The onion rings seemed to have their own batter on them which was slightly sweet but they were also phenomenal. Food came out quicker than I expected but we visted mid October, on a monday around 4:30pm, so the area wasn't very busy. Im sure the wait times during prime season might be longer but it would be worth the wait. It will most definitely be my first choice for food on my next vist to the falls.
Anthony G.
Fast and helpful service, good attitude, professional, BEST PIZZA OF BUFFALO I love the family comittment and heritage. Funny TMMT ninja turtles donatello references. Pizza came fast, perfect, and intense! Perfect proportions and presentation! Great deals and prices. You cannot beat this place! 99/100 i will choose to eat here when im around the area. They reign supreme! Thankful for the helpful lady with tattoos upfront!